Skip to content

Former Police Officer. Licensed Psychologist.

Returning to Therapy After a Bad Fit

Practical questions to bring into a conversation with Scott.

A Guide for adults

A previous mismatch can give you useful questions for the next consultation. You do not need to dismiss what happened or assume the next experience will be the same.

William Scott Ivey · Licensed Psychologist · California PSY 28279

Describe the mismatch in concrete terms

Perhaps the pace felt wrong, the goals were unclear or the conversations seemed to miss the reason you came. You may have a different concern entirely. It helps to describe the part you would want handled differently, without needing to supply the whole treatment history. A specific concern gives a prospective therapist a chance to explain how they work and what they can reasonably offer.

Separate a fit question from a verdict

I cannot judge another clinician's entire practice from a brief conversation. I can listen to what did not work for you and answer questions about my own approach. You are not required to defend your decision to stop with someone else. If the concern involves possible misconduct, that is a separate issue from choosing a new therapist and may need information beyond a consultation about treatment.

Ask about the part that matters most

If you disliked feeling argued with, ask how a therapist handles disagreement. If you were unsure why you were doing something, ask how the purpose of an exercise is explained. If sessions drifted, ask how goals are reviewed. My ACT and Narrative approach centers on options and the language used to understand your life. You can ask what that would mean for your particular concern.

Check the practical reasons too

A workable relationship also depends on scheduling, fees and the setting for sessions. I am private pay only: $195 for 55 minutes by video, with a free 15 minute phone consult. Ask about current availability and consider whether the session fee and a private setting fit your circumstances.

Keep permission to evaluate the new work

You do not have to promise yourself that this time you will stay no matter what. We can discuss what you want to notice in early sessions and how to bring up concerns. A change in approach may be useful, or a different service may be more appropriate. No consultation can guarantee a match, but it can make the next decision more informed than choosing from a description alone.

Questions you can bring

  • What specifically would I want handled differently?
  • What question would help me understand this therapist's approach?
  • How will we discuss concerns if the new work misses my goals?

Use the free consultation to ask the questions your last experience left you with. A short request to discuss fit is enough to begin; detailed records do not belong in the contact form.

Fees in Brief

Private pay only: $195 for 55 minutes by video. Free 15 minute consult.

Rates in detail

Start with what matters to you.

Request a free 15-minute consultation. By video across California.